How Coaches and Fitness Instructors Can Use Persuasion Principles to Attract More Clients

Published: 18 Jun 2024

As a coach or fitness instructor, attracting and retaining clients can be a challenge. But what if you could harness the power of psychology to make your services irresistible? Based on the book Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion by Robert Cialdini, here are six fundamental principles of persuasion that can help you boost your sales and grow your client base.

1. The Brain Loves Shortcuts

Our brains are wired to seek shortcuts because reflecting on every decision we make is exhausting. This can be leveraged in several ways:

Reasoning Technique

Ever noticed how people are more likely to comply with a request if given a reason, even if it’s nonsensical? In an experiment, a woman asked to skip the queue for a photocopy machine, and she was successful simply by saying, “because I need to make copies.” As a coach, you can use this by giving logical (or even seemingly trivial) reasons for why someone should join your programme. For example, “Join my coaching session because it’s designed to accelerate your success.”

Price-Quality Shortcut

People often associate price with quality. If you price your services too low, potential clients might think they’re not valuable. By positioning your services as high-value through appropriate pricing, you can attract clients who are looking for quality results. Remember, sometimes higher prices can actually boost your credibility and perceived value.

2. Humans Have a Need to Return Favours

Reciprocity is a powerful principle. When someone does us a favour, we feel compelled to return it.

Small Favours

Offer a free initial consultation or a valuable resource like an e-book or webinar. This small gesture can create a sense of indebtedness, making clients more likely to sign up for your paid services. Think of it as giving sweets with the bill in a restaurant – a small touch that makes a big impact.

Creating Favourable First Impressions

Nathan, a fitness coach, often gives his new clients a personalised workout plan after their first free session. This small favour not only helps clients feel valued but also makes them more likely to commit to his paid services. It’s all about starting the relationship on a positive note.

How Coaches And Fitness Instructors Can Use Persuasion Principles To Attract More Clients
Portrait of a happy job applicant standing in line with a group of unidentifiable businesspeople.

3. Negotiate with an Outrageous Request

This principle involves making an initial request that’s likely to be rejected, followed by a more reasonable request. This makes the second request seem much more acceptable.

Rejection and Retreat Technique

Start with a higher offer and retreat to a more reasonable one. For example, Ned, a personal trainer, initially offers an all-inclusive 12-month training package. When potential clients hesitate, he offers a more modest 3-month package. The clients often accept the smaller offer because it seems much more reasonable by comparison.

4. Desire Increases When an Object is Scarce

Scarcity drives desire. Limited availability, competition, and urgency can make your services more attractive.

Limited Availability

Promote your coaching sessions as exclusive and limited. Highlight that you only have a few spots left. This creates urgency and motivates potential clients to act quickly.

Competitive Edge

Create a sense of competition by showing how others are interested. Share testimonials and success stories to fuel this. For example, Nathan shares before-and-after photos of clients who have achieved great results. This not only showcases his expertise but also creates a sense of urgency for new clients to sign up before slots fill up.

5. The Power of Consistency

People like to stay consistent with their commitments. Once they commit to something, they’re more likely to stick with it.

Small Commitments

Encourage potential clients to make small commitments. This could be signing up for a newsletter or attending a free event. These small steps increase their likelihood of committing to larger goals, like a full coaching programme.

Show Progress

Keep track of your clients’ progress and remind them of their commitment. This can reinforce their dedication and motivate them to continue. For example, Ned regularly updates his clients on their progress, which helps them stay committed to their fitness goals.

6. Harness Social Proof

People look to others for cues on how to behave, especially in uncertain situations. Social proof can build credibility and trust.

Showcase Testimonials

Display reviews and success stories prominently on your website and social media. Highlight how others have benefitted from your coaching. This can reassure potential clients that they’re making the right choice.

Create a Community

Foster a sense of community where clients can share their experiences. For example, Nathan created a private Facebook group for his clients to share their fitness journeys, ask questions, and support each other. This not only provides social proof but also builds a supportive network that encourages client retention.

How Coaches And Fitness Instructors Can Use Persuasion Principles To Attract More Clients
Cant end the night without a selfie.

Enhance Likability

People are more likely to comply with someone they like. Building likability can be a game-changer.

Personal Connection

Build rapport by being relatable and approachable. Use genuine flattery and find common ground with your clients. For example, Ned makes an effort to learn about his clients’ interests and hobbies, creating a more personal connection.

Attractive Branding

Ensure your branding and personal presentation are appealing and professional. Your online presence should reflect your personality and professionalism, making you more likable and trustworthy.

Assert Authority

People obey authority figures without question. Establishing yourself as an authority can win compliance effortlessly.

Expertise Display

Share your credentials, achievements, and professional titles. Publish articles, speak at events, and wear professional attire that reinforces your expertise. For example, Nathan regularly posts articles and videos showcasing his fitness knowledge, which establishes him as an authority in the field.

Symbols of Authority

Use visuals and environments that denote professionalism. Clean, well-decorated coaching spaces with comfortable seating and pleasant artwork can reinforce your authority.

Putting It All Together

By understanding and applying these principles of persuasion, you can significantly improve your ability to attract and retain clients. It’s all about leveraging psychology to create a compelling and trustworthy coaching service that resonates with potential clients on a deeper level.


Example Scenario: Nathan and Ned

Nathan and Ned, both fitness coaches, decided to apply these principles to attract more clients.

  • Nathan’s Approach: Nathan started by offering a free initial consultation (reciprocity) and provided personalised workout plans. He showcased client success stories on social media (social proof) and highlighted that his coaching slots were limited (scarcity). He also built a private Facebook group for his clients, fostering a supportive community.
  • Ned’s Strategy: Ned offered a 12-month training package initially (outrageous request), then retreated to a 3-month package when clients hesitated. He regularly updated his clients on their progress (consistency) and made an effort to build personal connections by learning about their interests (likability). He also shared his credentials and achievements through blog posts and videos (authority).

Both Nathan and Ned saw a significant increase in client sign-ups and retention by leveraging these persuasion principles.

Take Action Now!

Ready to take your coaching business to the next level? Sign up for exclusive tips and resources on how to attract more clients at IFIGrow Membership.

And for more insights into the psychology of persuasion, don’t forget to check out Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion by Robert Cialdini.

Explore Our Latest Articles

Unlock your potential and grow with every challenge

Unlock your potential and grow with every challenge

Copyright © 2024 If I Grow